A Final View of a Castle on Staten Island Before It’s Demolished
For 124 years, a castle with many names dominated the serene neighborhood of Thompkinsville, Staten Island. The enchanting red brick chateau, nestled on a picturesque six-acre hilltop cloaked in crawling vines, possessed an allure akin to a fairy tale setting. However, three decades-long neglect transformed this once-majestic structure into a haunting Gothic horror. In the early morning of a brisk March in 2012, while most of the island’s inhabitants slumbered, wrecking balls converged upon the Frost Memorial Tower of the old Samuel R. Smith Infirmary. In a matter of hours, the hospital succumbed to the relentless force, reducing it to a pile of rubble. Scores of onlookers gathered to witness the sad demise of an architectural gem.
The debris-laden lot symbolizes the lost history and dashed hopes for the Preservation League of Staten Island and its ardent supporters. Despite their vibrant and repeated endeavors to salvage the tower, the Landmarks Preservation Commission remained steadfast in their decision. City engineers assessing the building’s structural integrity verified it was in a progressive collapse. Consequently, it posed a grave peril to firefighters entering the premises during a conflagration.
Named in honor of a compassionate physician dedicated to caring for the indigent, the Samuel R. Smith Infirmary was established in 1863 as Staten Island’s inaugural private hospital. Generously funded through extravagant charity balls, the institution became the cherished undertaking of the borough’s affluent social elite, fondly referred to as the “Pride of Staten Island.” As the twentieth century approached, the Infirmary outgrew its original abode, prompting the laying of the cornerstone for a grand edifice known as the Frost Memorial Tower. This name was bestowed in honor of the benevolent benefactor who had graciously donated the picturesque hilly land. The tower was destined to become one of Staten Island’s most distinguished landmarks.
While initially established to cater to the needs of the impoverished, the Smith Infirmary soon opened its doors to the general public. It underwent a name change in 1916, becoming the Staten Island Hospital. The institution served as a medical haven for many individuals, including notable actors, lawyers, political figures, and patients shrouded in mystery. In 1907, an unfortunate incident stained the history of the Infirmary when a doctor met his untimely demise at the hands of a vengeful husband whose wife had passed away during a surgical procedure. The damning evidence, which ultimately led to the perpetrator’s execution, can still be witnessed at Cypress Hills Cemetery. Upon his wife’s grave lies the haunting epitaph: “Revenge renews our happy love in heaven forever.”
By 1974, the once-rural environs surrounding the complex had succumbed to rapid urbanization, leaving minimal space for expansion. During this period, a hundred patients were left waiting daily for admission, while parking issues exacerbated the situation. Consequently, in 1979, the hospital relocated to a new facility on Seaview Avenue, abandoning its former campus.
In 1983, despite the building’s architectural and historical significance, the Landmarks Preservation Commission decided not to grant the Smith Infirmary’s signature structure landmark status. The hospital’s dilapidated state and location in a deteriorating neighborhood had garnered an unsavory reputation, often associated with illicit activities. Bestowing landmark status on the site would have hindered potential redevelopment efforts. Consequently, the land became a prime target for various residential development proposals that still need to materialize. As the building continued to decay, it became a hotbed for real estate fraud and a refuge for the local homeless community. Nevertheless, many community members held a deep sentimental attachment to the structure, affectionately dubbing it “the Castle.”
Over 33 years of abandonment, the once-majestic walls, sagging ceilings, and hazardous floors of the Infirmary succumbed entirely to the ravages of time and the elements. The stench of mold and decay permeated the interior while gusts of wind forcefully swept through the second-floor landing, causing boards and debris to collide and create unsettling noises. These were the final gasps of a squandered architectural treasure. May the Staten Island Castle rest in eternal pieces, a solemn testament to a bygone era.
The tale of Staten Island Castle, formerly known as the Samuel R. Smith Infirmary, embodies a tragic narrative of neglect and lost history. Despite vigorous efforts by preservationists and the local community, the building’s structural deterioration and safety concerns led to its demolition. Today, only remnants and memories remain, serving as a poignant reminder of the fleeting nature of architectural treasures. Let the story of Staten Island Castle inspire us to cherish and preserve our historical landmarks, ensuring that they endure for generations to come.
Note: We do not own any of the images here and all images are copyrighted to their original owners. Please contact us if you wish to remove anything
